About Us

Aged Asiago, the ultimate bold cheese adventure, is your ally against ghouls or mealtime monotony. Break a piece, dip, and savor its unique character – it's the unrivaled Asiago after nearly 3 years of perfection. Click to View

Aged Goat Gouda, a Dutch-style masterpiece crafted with goat's milk, is the cheese equivalent of savoring exquisite dark chocolate. It leaves you spellbound, a silent poet entranced by its indescribable Click to View

Aged Goat Milk Cheddar is a remarkable goat's milk Cheddar, matured for two years to perfection. Its rich, full-bodied flavor will delight your taste buds with every Click to View

Our Aged Gorgonzola, a sweet dolce style cheese, is aged an extra few months or more, resulting in a creamy texture and a subtly sweet finish. While it's a bit milder than our Aged Buttermilk Bleu, it's sure to leave you delightfully "bleu'n" away with its unique flavor. Click to View

Our Aged Parmesan, matured for three years, is so divine you'll want to savor it anywhere – on its own, in the kitchen, or even in a moat! It's the best Parmesan you've ever tasted, enhancing every dish with its unparalleled richness. Click to View

Applewood Smoked Cheddar is a three-year-old white cheddar, gently smoked in-house, delivering a mouthwatering combination of rich, sweet, and smoky flavors that'll have you craving more with every bite. It's a true taste Click to View

Our Applewood Smoked Gouda is a Maple Leaf young Gouda, lovingly smoked in-house, making it one of our most beloved cheeses. Its subtly sweet, reserved smoky character sets it apart from the usual hickory smoked versions, making it a delightful treat for all ages and a favorite among our younger cheese Click to View

Our Applewood Smoked String cheese is a labor of love, hand-stretched by Cesar himself and gently kissed by fresh applewood smoke. It's a reinvented classic, giving you a taste experience like no other, far beyond your memories of the smoked string cheese from your youth. Click to View

Our Apricot Triple Creme is a luxurious experience, featuring layers of St. Andre, a French triple creme cheese, toasted almonds, and apricots. It's like a sophisticated twist on butter and jam, perfect for spreading on a baguette or adding a delicate layer to your French Toast – a truly delightful and life-extending Click to View

Our Bleu Triple Creme Brie is an exquisite creation, featuring a French triple creme cheese layered with Buttermilk Bleu. It's like the heavenly topping they serve on burgers in the afterlife – pure indulgence with a touch of divine blue cheese Click to View

Cesar's hand-pulled String Cheese is a labor of love, meticulously hand-stretched by Cesar and Heydi. It's an absolute masterpiece, promising a cheese experience like no other – the best you've ever Click to View

Chandoka Cheddar, a blend of cow and goat milk, is a delightful masterpiece, aged for over three years, delivering a truly unique and exquisite experience akin to aged milk candy. It's a cheese gem reserved for those with a taste for the extraordinary. Click to View

Our Aged 13 Years Cheddar is a true cheese time capsule, a journey through the years, with all the crunch, tang, and explosive flavor you could ever desire. It's a cheese experience that takes you back while delivering unmatched richness. Click to View

Colby Swiss is the everyday cheese hero, blending the goodness of Colby and the distinctive Amish Swiss finish. It's a cheese that starts with a familiar Colby charm and ends with the delightful character of Amish Swiss.

Creamy Amish Swiss is like Stettler's signature, a young Swiss cheese, boasting a soft texture reminiscent of Havarti but with a subtle touch of unique character – it's the perfect addition to your sandwich parties. Get ready for a creamily delicious experience with just a hint of that special cheese charm. Click to View

Donatello is the cheese connoisseur's dream, akin to a well-aged, buttery Manchego, but with an even more exceptional character. Crafted with sheep's milk, it's a taste experience that transcends traditional expectations. Click to View

Double-Aged Cupola is a delightful American Parmesan with surprising notes of caramel and toasted pineapple, making it an exciting twist on the classic. This cheese offers a unique flavor experience that's bound to tantalize your taste buds. Click to View

Double-Aged Delft Bleu is like a Gouda meets Bleu cheese collaboration, usually mild-mannered and polite, but after two years in our caves, they become distinguished cheese stars with a bold character. This cheese deserves a starring role on your steak – it's a flavor transformation worth savoring generously! Click to View

Ewephoria's Select is a delightful twist on traditional Dutch Gouda, meticulously crafted with pasteurized sheep's milk, and aged for 24 months. Each bite unveils a mild, enchanting butterscotch undertone, making it perfect for cheeseboards, gourmet recipes, or savoring on its own – a truly harmonious and unique cheese experience. Click to View

Extra Aged Fourmage, a harmonious blend of buffalo, sheep, cow, and goat milk, creates a creamy masterpiece that's an unforgettable experience for your palate. With two years of aging, the velvety buffalo milk and sweet sheep milk undertones truly make the flavors sing and stand out, especially when paired with succulent pears, juicy peaches, or luscious figs. Click to View

The kitchen magician for an instant tangy twist, perfect for pasta, omelettes, burgers, cheesecakes, and even as a thoughtful wedding gift. Its clean, non-animal taste sets it apart from other goat cheeses. Click to View

Fresh Curds - Dill & Garlic, crafted by our in-house milk magician Dan Posselt, are a true old-fashioned delight. These hand-milled curds are a perfect balance of garlic and dill, ensuring each bite bursts with irresistible flavor. Click to View

Fresh Curds - Plain, crafted by our in-house milk magician Dan Posselt, are a delightful old-fashioned treat. Hand-milled to perfection, they're a pure and simple cheese delight that's perfect for all cheese lovers. Click to View

Our Garlic Herb Spread is a sumptuous blend of sweet cream and Mascarpone, infused with the robust flavors of garlic and aromatic herbs. It's the perfect companion for your bagels, crackers, or as a savory addition to your culinary creations. Click to View

Our Goat Milk Feta is a delightful paradox, offering a salty, crumbly, and tart experience while maintaining a moist and fudgy texture that's simply irresistible. Crafted by the talented folks at LaClare Creamery in Malone, WI, using milk from their own herd, it's the perfect addition to your cheese platter or culinary creations. Click to View

Great-Grand Cheddar, aged in-house for an extraordinary 8 years, is a testament to our unwavering commitment to creating exceptional cheese. This masterpiece offers a remarkable balance of sweet and tangy flavors, complete with the irresistible crunchiness that defines the finest aged cheeses, inviting you to savor the essence of time and craftsmanship in every remarkable bite. Click to View

Heritage Aged Cheddar, the sibling of Weiss Cheddar, is a one-of-a-kind sharp, white cheddar that's been aged for over 7 years. This "gassy" cheddar boasts extra flavors and a unique depth, creating a remarkable and distinct cheddar experience. Click to View

HoneyBee Goat Gouda is a delightful Dutch-style Gouda, lovingly crafted with goat's milk, and enhanced with a drizzle of honey that infuses it with a cashew-like, nutty sweetness. This cheese offers a subtly sweet and full-flavored experience that's perfect for slicing, grating, cubing, or enjoying in salads and as a snack with your favorite fruits.

House-Aged White Cheddar, akin to our Great-Grand Cheddar but not quite as old, is an extra-sharp cheddar that marries a smooth, creamy finish with its bold flavor profile. Aged for a minimum of 5 years, it's the secret ingredient that elevates your Mac n' Cheese to culinary perfection, delivering a delightful sharpness that your taste buds won't soon forget. Click to View

House Aged Buttermilk Blue, sourced from Roth Kase in Monroe, is a delightful and aged blue cheese that offers the same exquisite character as Bleu Affinee but with the added dimension of being aged in-house. Its unique aging process creates a bold, robust flavor profile that's perfect for those who appreciate a little extra complexity in their blue cheese.

House-Smoked Mindoro Bleu takes our extra-aged Mindoro Bleu wheels and elevates them to a new level with an in-house smoking process. This bold cheese is the perfect winter remedy when smeared on steak, offering a delightful combination of rich smokiness and tangy blue cheese flavor that will chase away any winter blues. Click to View

Kickaas Applewood Smoked Habanero Jack is a tantalizing fusion of sweet, fruity heat and a touch of smokiness that adds a fiery kick to your culinary creations. Handcrafted by our cheesemaker Dan Posselt and smoked in-house, it's the secret ingredient that amps up your cooking, providing a flavorful symphony for your taste buds. Click to View

Kickaas Chipotle Espresso Cheddar is a flavor explosion featuring smoked jalapeños infused with a spicy tomato marinade, elevated by Dark Matter's Unicorn Blood espresso. Despite its fiery appearance, it offers a balanced heat that's perfect for adding a kick to scrambled eggs, quesadillas, or complementing a glass of peaty Scotch. Crafted by our cheesemaker Dan Posselt, it's a cheese that resembles Jupiter up close, both in appearance and its ability to transport your taste buds to a world of bold, smoky flavors. Click to View

Kickaas Jack N Dill, a full cream Jack cheese infused with fresh dill, is anything but straightforward – it's a magical taste journey that's akin to a fairytale. Crafted by the regal Dan Posselt, our in-house monarch of fromage, it delivers a whimsical blend of creaminess and dill that enchants your palate with every bite. Click to View

Kickaas Jack with Fresh Basil is a delightful creation that combines the essence of sweet and opal basil, handcrafted by our in-house milk magician, Dan Posselt. The result is a creamy Jack cheese infused with the aromatic and herbaceous notes of basil, making it a delightful addition to your cheese board and culinary creations. Click to View

Maasdaam is a Dutch interpretation of Swiss cheese, aged for at least 2 years, offering the perfect fusion of Swiss and Gouda characteristics. With delightful Swiss flavor that concludes with buttery notes, it's a cheese that satisfies with every bite, bridging two classic cheese traditions in a single wheel. Click to View

Marieke Aged Gouda is a masterpiece of cheese craftsmanship, created with milk straight from the cows and transformed into cheese within hours of milking. Aged as close to a year as possible, this Dutch-style Gouda is celebrated for its amazing flavor that evolves gradually on your tongue from start to finish, complete with those delightful crunchy bits. Click to View

Marieke Foenegreek Gouda is a delightful young Gouda enriched with Fenugreek seeds, offering a creamy and subtly maple syrup-like sweetness that evokes hints of French toast. It's a cheese that invites you to savor the fusion of flavors, providing a unique and memorable taste experience. Click to View

Marieke Gouda Spread takes a younger Marieke Gouda and transforms it into a delectable spread, boasting the classic flavors that Marieke Gouda is celebrated for. As the original spread from Marieke, it's a true essential that deserves a permanent spot in your fridge, perfect for adding a touch of Gouda excellence to your favorite dishes. Click to View

Marieke Gouda with Cranberry is a delightful blend of rich and tart flavors that elevate your culinary creations, making it the perfect addition to your turkey sandwich or any dish in need of a gourmet touch. With each bite, you'll experience a burst of exquisite taste that brings a touch of sophistication to your meals. Click to View

Marieke Hatch Pepper Gouda Spread strikes the perfect balance of spice, adding a mild but enticing kick that's certain to elevate your cracker game. Beware, it's so irresistibly delicious that you'll find yourself ordering more before you know it, making it a must-have in your kitchen. Click to View

Marieke Gouda Honey Clover is a cheese that beautifully balances sweetness and earthiness, with subtle hints of fresh grass that make it a delightful addition to your cheese board. It pairs exceptionally well with apples and walnuts, and when accompanied by Riesling or hard cider, it creates a symphony of flavors that enhance your tasting experience. Click to View

Marieke Honey Clover Gouda Spread takes the sweet essence of Honey Clover Gouda and transforms it into a luscious spread that offers a symphony of flavors. You'll savor the initial sweetness of honey and cheese, followed by the savory notes of clover, creating an irresistible and addictively good spread that elevates your culinary creations. Click to View

Marieke Mustard Seed Gouda is a cheese of rich heritage and artisan craftsmanship. Made with premium, raw cow's milk from the Penterman family farm and aged on Dutch pine planks for over 9 months, this cheese showcases the creamy, earthy flavors of Gouda, accentuated by the presence of black and yellow mustard seeds. Click to View

Marieke Nettle Gouda is a flavorful delight that captures the essence of Dutch heritage, crafted with premium, raw cow's milk from the Penterman family farm. Handcrafted using herbs and seeds sourced from the Netherlands, this Gouda offers a creamy, herbaceous profile with captivating notes of garlic and parsley that create an unforgettable tasting experience. Click to View

Marieke Gouda Summer Fields is a smooth, rich Gouda cheese adorned with fragrant herbs of rosemary and thyme. Perfectly paired with apples, walnuts, Riesling, or hard cider, it's a delightful addition to your cheese board that harmonizes flavors with elegance. Click to View

Marieke Truffle Gouda is a young, savory sensation infused with the enchanting essence of truffle, creating a taste experience that's irresistibly delicious. With its captivating truffle notes, it's a must-have cheese for those who appreciate the exquisite fusion of earthy and umami flavors in their culinary Click to View

Experience a symphony of rich, crystalline aged gouda notes harmoniously balanced with the velvety creaminess of youth in the limited-edition Marieke Gouda Reserve—a delectable treat for true cheese enthusiasts. Marieke Gouda Reserve